When IntelliJ IDEA imports WALA's Gradle configuration, it creates
what is calls a "module" for each sourceSet of each Gradle subproject.
In so doing, it automatically picks up the source and resource
directories used by each of these sourceSets. Unfortunately, IntelliJ
IDEA does not allow multiple modules to share a single root directory
as their source or resource directories, and that's exactly what was
going on with the "example-src" subdirectory under
"com.ibm.wala.cast.js.test.data".
This revised Gradle configuration still has is copying the necessary
"example-src" resources to the appropriate locations for use as test
resources. But IntelliJ IDEA no longer treats "example-src" as a root
directory for resources in the automatically-generated modules. So
now we get along nicer with IntelliJ IDEA while keeping everything
working with Gradle as well.
WALA itself does not use any JUnit 4.12 features. However, I am
working on a WALA-based project that does require JUnit 4.12. Mixing
jar versions is a path to madness. So if the WALA maintainers don't
mind, it would make my life easier if WALA itself required JUnit 4.12.
Otherwise, I need to maintain that 4.11/4.12 difference indefinitely
as a divergence between official WALA and my WALA variant.
I suppose an alternative could be to let the JUnit version be
specified externally somehow. I have not explored this option in
depth, but could look into it if simply moving to JUnit 4.12 is
undesirable.
This gives the WALA maintainers the option of doing future 1.4.5+
releases from of a pre-Gradle branch if these merged Gradle changes
turn out to be more disruptive than expected.
These settings files currently are generated with an initial timestamp
comment line, which is not something we'd want to track in version
control. Fortunately, the contents of these files are entirely
mundane, so there should be no problem with having Buildship generate
them anew each time a developer imports WALA into Eclipse as an
existing Gradle project.
Apparently Buildship generates these when one uses Import -> Existing
Gradle Project:
<https://discuss.gradle.org/t/buildship-eclipse-plug-in-multiproject-builds/24030/5>.
We can use the Gradle "eclipse" plugin if customizations are
necessary, but my impression is that the intent is to treat ".project"
and ".classpath" as generated files, not sources to be tracked in
source control.
I was confused about the differences among:
srcDir 'foo'
srcDirs ['foo']
srcDirs = ['foo']
As it turns out, the first two append to the set of source
directories, while the last replaces this set entirely. I generally
want replacement, since WALA's current directory layout never matches
Gradle's assumed defaults.
The main requirement here is to arrange for the proper classpath
settings when tests are running so that they can find any associated
resources (i.e., other supporting files).
This gives the WALA maintainers the option of doing future 1.4.5+
releases from of a pre-Gradle branch if these merged Gradle changes
turn out to be more disruptive than expected.
These settings files currently are generated with an initial timestamp
comment line, which is not something we'd want to track in version
control. Fortunately, the contents of these files are entirely
mundane, so there should be no problem with having Buildship generate
them anew each time a developer imports WALA into Eclipse as an
existing Gradle project.
Apparently Buildship generates these when one uses Import -> Existing
Gradle Project:
<https://discuss.gradle.org/t/buildship-eclipse-plug-in-multiproject-builds/24030/5>.
We can use the Gradle "eclipse" plugin if customizations are
necessary, but my impression is that the intent is to treat ".project"
and ".classpath" as generated files, not sources to be tracked in
source control.
I was confused about the differences among:
srcDir 'foo'
srcDirs ['foo']
srcDirs = ['foo']
As it turns out, the first two append to the set of source
directories, while the last replaces this set entirely. I generally
want replacement, since WALA's current directory layout never matches
Gradle's assumed defaults.
The main requirement here is to arrange for the proper classpath
settings when tests are running so that they can find any associated
resources (i.e., other supporting files).
These are all problems that Eclipse can detect, but that it detects no
instances of right now. Treating these as warnings instead of errors
should help prevent us from slipping backward in the future.
Previously we had 5 such warnings. That's not very many, but it
suggests that the WALA developers consider this to be an acceptable
coding style. If that's so, then it's better to hide these warnings
rather than keep them around as a perpetual distraction.
I have *not* upgraded this problem to be treated as an error in the
future. Unfortunately Eclipse uses a single configuration setting for
both unnecessary semicolons and also for empty control-flow statements
like `while (p) ;`. I'm not convinced that it's worth rewriting all
instances of the latter into `while (p) { }`. So this is just going
to stay as a warning for now.
There are two such diagnostics: one for collection methods and one for
equals(). See
<https://www.eclipse.org/eclipse/news/4.7/jdt.php#unlikely-argument-types>
for more information about these two new diagnostics.
For each of these diagnostics, I've set the severity level to
"warning" in projects that have some instances of the suspicious code,
or to "error" in projects that have no instances of the suspicious
code.
These should mostly be things that we've already decided earlier that
we explicitly don't want to "fix" because they simply disagree with
the WALA project's coding style.
The additional diagnostics are ones that were previously being
ignored, but which we seem to have been ignoring by default rather
than as a conscious choice.
For diagnostics of which we currently have *zero* instances, treat
these as errors rather than merely warnings. The intent is to
permanently lock out future regressions of things we've completely
fixed. In the future, whenever we fix the last instance of a given
warning in a given Eclipse project, we should also promote that
diagnostic to an error to keep things clean into the future.
This fixes five Eclipse "Source folder '...' does not have the output
folder in corresponding output entry 'output..'" warnings in the
"Plug-in Development" category.
Specifically, these are all warnings of the form "The
'javacProjectSettings' build entry should be set when there are project
specific compiler settings".